hide You are viewing an archived web page collected at the request of University of Alberta using Archive-It. This page was captured on 16:06:15 Dec 08, 2010, and is part of the HCF Alberta Online Encyclopedia collection. The information on this web page may be out of date. See All versions of this archived page. Loading media information
Heritage Community Foundation Presents
Alberta Online Encyclopedia
When Coal Was King
Industry, People and Challenges
Heritage Community Foundation, Year of the Coalminer, Albertasource and Cultural Capital of Canada logos

Home     |      About     |      Contact Us     |      Sponsors     |      Sitemap     |      Search

1919 Coal Mining Commission

After a period of intense labour unrest with strikes throughout the Province of Alberta's mines, a government-appointed Commission was established in spring, 1919, to study the industry. The Commission began its hearings after the Winnipeg General Strike and also after the strike in Drumheller, which lasted longer than the General Strike. Alberta miners were among the most militant and supported the UMWA and also the One Big Union. The sources of contention included conditions and hours of work, wages and job security.

The Commission Chair was John T. Stirling, a Scotsman who had arrived in Canada in 1908 and had become the Chief Inspector of Mines for Alberta in 1910. He was viewed as knowledgeable and trustworthy by both industry and workers. The miners' representative was John Loughran, an Irish immigrant who had worked in the mines of the Crowsnest Pass and who was a member of the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA). Employers were represented by Walter F. McNeill, an American-born mine manager who operated from 1895 the McNeill Brothers Coal Mines in Canmore. Other representatives included Walter Smitten, a member of the Bricklayers and Stonemasons International Union and secretary of the Alberta Federation of Labour; Harvey Shaw, owner of the North West Biscuit Company and member of the Board of Trade in Edmonton.

It was not just mine issues that had resulted in the industrial action. Some miners were influenced by the Russian Revolution and the coming to power of Lenin and saw themselves as a part of an international workers movement. As David Bercuson notes in his introduction to Alberta's Coal Industry, 1919 (Calgary, Alberta: the Historical Society of Alberta, 1978):

The January, 1919, convention of the Alberta Federation of Labor to which the coal miners were affiliated through the UMWA, and the February convention of District 28 of the United Mine Workers, went on record in favour of worker control of industry, the use of general strikes to force political and industrial change, and the amalgamation of craft unions into larger, more powerful industrial unions. In addition, they expressed sympathy for the new Bolshevik regime in Russia.

Hearings began on October 6th and lasted until November 26th and were held in the following coal mining centres:

  • Edmonton
  • Calgary
  • Drumheller
  • Lethbridge
  • Wayne
  • Edson and
  • Blairmore

The hearings revealed poor working and living conditions and also exploitation of miners by companies not only in over-priced company stores but also in mine camps where the food was over-priced and of poor quality. For their part, the operators denied responsibility and blamed the radicals for the problems.

The Coal Mining Commission Report was issued on December 23rd, 1919. As Bercuson notes, the Report is invaluable to labour and social historians and is more than 900 typed, legal-sized pages. Bercuson has provided diverse extracts from the hearings, which capture the flavour of the testimony and the polarization of labour and management presenters. Bercuson notes:

What is published is a summary view of the Alberta coal mining industry in the period immediately after World War One. Here are the ambitions and fears of entrepreneurs risking capital to bring profits to themselves and development to the community. Here are the typical complaints of western businessmen about a system which they claimed discriminated against them to the benefit of Central Canada. Here also are the grievances of miners, most of whom sought only fair compensation for their labour and living conditions fit for humans. The evidence clearly shows the squalor and misery of the coal towns, and the struggles of the miners and their families in those communities for a decent life style and for educational opportunities for their children. The evidence presented to the Coal Mining Industry Commission of 1919 gives us the story of an important western industry, told by the people who lived it.

bottom spacer

Albertasource.ca | Contact Us | Partnerships
            For more on coal mining in Western Canada, visit Peel’s Prairie Provinces.
Copyright © Heritage Communty Foundation All Rights Reserved