Well the Miracle of the Roadstar has occured! Last night I tapped on the starter with the padded handle of a pair of pliers and also tapped on the fuel pump just for good measure. I told her to start acting right and left it overnight. This morning I put the battery charger back on it and left it for several hours. When it was fully charged, I pulled the choke and vroom, she started right up. Roadstar, heal thyself! I have no idea why it worked, but I claiming it had to do with the heart-to-heart I had with her last night
Whatever the cause, I'm happy!