hide You are viewing an archived web page, collected at the request of Indiana University Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) using Archive-It. This page was captured on 14:12:49 Jul 15, 2020, and is part of the University Records collection. The information on this web page may be out of date. See All versions of this archived page. Loading media information |
Open Peer Review for the Humanities

What is Open Peer Review?

Permalink for this paragraph 0 Simply put, open peer review is the process of allowing one’s work to be reviewed by a wide audience.  It differs from “double-blind” review in that neither author nor reviewer is anonymous.  Furthermore, it opens review and comment to a much larger readership.  We all participate in open peer review from time-to-time without thinking about it.  For example, when we share our work at a conference, we are participating in a live version of the open review process.

Permalink for this paragraph 0 Digital open peer review is rapidly being accepted as a normal part of the scholarly production in the STEM subjects and in the Social Sciences.  Although it has not replaced more traditional forms of peer review, it has become a fixture of the academic publishing world.

Permalink for this paragraph 0 In the humanities, however, its impact is much less marked.  Not only have there been very few experiments in open peer review — Shakespeare Quarterly’s use of CommentPress being the most prominent — but there has been little work to assess the impact its eventual introduction will have on the humanities.  This is beginning to change.  A number of digital journals are in development including Open Canister, a media studies journal with which the History Working Papers Project is working closely.  Furthermore, the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation has recently funded a year-long study of peer-to-peer (P2P) review under the leadership of MediaCommons and New York University Press; while the Center for History and the New Media, has just announced its PressForward project, designed to incorporate online peer review within a wholly digital environment.

Permalink for this paragraph 0 So while open peer review has yet to substantially effect the humanities, it is set to become an important element of the humanities project in the next few years.

page 9